Average Jane Channels Mary Richards

Remember the running joke on "The Mary Tyler Moore Show" about Mary’s parties?  Basically, all of her parties were complete disasters, usually because nobody showed up. 

Last night I had my second party in less than a month where the turnout was ridiculously low.  I’m thinking of giving up on entertaining altogether.

My first party disaster was in mid-December.  I can kind of understand why it wasn’t particularly popular:  it was one of those candle parties where the guests shop for things.  Now that I and most of my friends are in our late 30s, we’re pretty much over the whole shopping party concept.  I’m still a sucker for Pampered Chef parties, but not so much the other stuff.

However, I’d promised a friend that I would throw a candle party, so I invited 40 or so women that I thought might be interested.  The Evite showed that there would probably be 3-4 guests, but that sounded acceptable to me.  I cleaned my house, made a cheese ball, baked some cookies and waited for the guests to arrive.  My friend, the presenter, came and set up the candles.  We sat and chatted.  The party start time came and went.  We continued chatting.   An hour passed.  Nobody showed up.   My friend started putting away her candles.  I started putting away the food.  We parted ways and went on with our day.

My next event, a cookie exchange party, ended up okay.  I had a total of six guests, two of whom stayed into the evening to play games.

Then I decided to throw a gathering last night.  I’m friends with a group of women who meet most Wednesday evenings for dinner, wine and conversation.  Nobody had "called" this week, so I sent an e-mail to the group on Monday offering to make ham and bean soup, potato soup and cornbread.

Quite a few regulars declined for various reasons, and one person accepted.  There were at least 6-8 others who never replied at all, so I figured I’d have a smaller than usual group.  As it turned out, only the one person who replied that she would be there actually showed up.

So there we were:  two women, two big pots of soup, two batches of cornbread and a bottle of Zinfandel.  Both soups were lovely – I had a bowl of each.  We drank most of the bottle of wine and had a nice time discussing politics, work and travel.  Eventually my husband came home and helped polish off a little bit more of the soup.

I can’t help wondering if I’m the problem here.  Are my parties boring?  Am I boring?  Is my house unpleasant in some way?  Do I just throw too many parties?

Whatever the problem is, I think I will try to cut back on my impulsive party throwing.  As much as I like having people over, it’s too much work and expense to go to if nobody attends.  Every year, fewer and fewer people bother to RSVP, even for my annual parties.  Among those who do respond, many of the "Yes"es fail to show, and I never count on the "Maybe"s. 

It’s time I sat back and played out my social life for a while as a guest instead of a host.  I’m sure it will be a lot cheaper and less frustrating.

Comments

9 responses to “Average Jane Channels Mary Richards”

  1. cagey Avatar

    sniff…. I LOVE your parties. As the flaker from the candle party – well, you know how bad I felt about that. I thought the cookie party went great, too.

  2. Jane Avatar

    Oh believe me, you weren’t the only flaker from the candle party! 😉

  3. Dorothy Avatar

    I think the main problem is the whole concept of “maybe” on evite. It should be just “yes” or “no,” then you know EXACTLY what to expect.
    I, too, have had some of those parties where nobody comes. My husband always assumes that will be the case and is shocked when people arrive. That is why I have taken my parties down to one a year, plus a bar crawl. The last pub crawl we invited 75 people and you saw the attendance – good, but not amazing. Have parties gone the way of the past???

  4. Dorothy Avatar

    BTW – I love your parties, your food and your house. It’s NOT YOU. Trust me.

  5. me Avatar

    I love your parties too! They are always lovely, and the food is spectacular. Please don’t stop throwing them. We love them!

  6. kevboy Avatar

    Jane, I’d show up if you had a soup party (and only if you invited me – don’t worry, I wouldn’t just show up ;-).
    Forget the candles – you could have 1/2 of your guests bring wine and the other 1/2 bring a soup. I’m talking homemade soup, too, not like a can of Progresso.
    When I was growing up, my mom would frequently boil a chicken (with carrots and celery, and dumplings if we were lucky) and then turn the broth and the leftover chicken into the best homemade chicken soup ever. The dumplings would make it thick, but they gave my dad heartburn, so she didn’t include those very often. When she didn’t, she’d put some egg noodles in when she heated the soup… I just made myself very hungry!

  7. Goofy Girl Avatar

    Having Goofy Junior, with his own agenda really puts the damper on party-going plans. I know I’ve flaked out on you several times this year. Keep having the parties! If there’s food involved, I’m more likely to come (evidenced by the cookie exchange – yum!)

  8. DivaM Avatar
    DivaM

    Awwww… I would attend your parties if I were your friend.

  9. marylynn Avatar

    I don’t know if your parties are boring. I’m certain they’re not. I love to throw parties, too, but it is getting harder and I think people are just getting ruder, frankly. Not RSVPing at all is not acceptable. Someone wants to welcome you into their home, feed/booze you, entertain you and the least you can do it reply politely. I’m also not a fan of the “Maybe”. Either you have plans at the time of the invitation or you do not and if you do not either you want to come or you do not. If you are busy or don’t want to come, just say No. If you are waiting for a better offer, say No. I hate Maybe’s.
    Even when I have a successful party, the 30 minutes before it’s due to start are nerve-wracking. I call it the “200 Cigarettes breakdown”.

Leave a Reply to Goofy Girl Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *